Short answer: In 2026 three mainstream providers document a phone-free signup: Tuta (free 1 GB, end-to-end encryption, some new accounts wait up to 48 hours for approval), Mailfence (free 500 MB, asks for a second email address instead) and Proton Mail (free 1 GB, may show a CAPTCHA, an email code or, occasionally, an SMS). Gmail sometimes asks for a phone and Outlook.com documents an email-based option without guaranteeing it. Yahoo, GMX, mail.com, Zoho and Apple’s web signup require a number.

The provider list, checked
The table below follows what each provider says about its own signup flow. Any of them can tighten the rules without notice, so treat the last column as the real test: does the flow let you finish without a number today.
| Provider | Phone at signup | What replaces it | Free storage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tuta | Phone-free route documented | Username and password, recovery code; new accounts can wait up to 48 hours | 1 GB |
| Mailfence | Phone-free route documented | Another email address receives the activation code | 500 MB |
| Proton Mail | Phone-free route documented | CAPTCHA, email code, or SMS on flagged signups | 1 GB |
| Gmail | Sometimes | Phone is listed as optional, Google can still demand it | 15 GB shared |
| Outlook.com | Email option documented | Alternate email as security info; not guaranteed | 15 GB |
| Yahoo Mail | Required | SMS code during signup | 1 TB |
| GMX | Required | SMS activation code | 1 GB |
| mail.com | Required | SMS activation code | 2 GB |
| Zoho Mail (free) | Required | Phone verified by code | 5 GB |
| iCloud Mail | Required on the web | Trusted phone number for two-factor | 5 GB |
| AOL Mail | Unclear | Code to a phone or email, depending on the screen | 250 GB |
Paid providers take the other route: Posteo (€1/month) and Mailbox.org (€1/month) accept anonymous payment and ask for no phone at all, and Runbox and StartMail are phone-free from the first screen. If the mailbox matters for years, paying €12 a year removes the argument.
How to sign up without a number
Tuta
- Open the Tuta signup page and pick the free plan.
- Choose a username and a strong password; Tuta offers a recovery code, and this is the only way back in if you lose the password.
- Solve the CAPTCHA. No phone number is requested.
- Some new accounts go into a manual review queue; the wait is quoted as up to 48 hours. Do not create a second account while waiting, since that makes review slower.
Mailfence
- Choose the free plan (500 MB).
- Enter the alternate email address where Mailfence sends the activation code.
- Click the link in that email. The alternate address becomes part of account recovery, so use one you still control.
Proton Mail
- Pick the free plan and a username.
- Complete the human check. Depending on traffic, Proton shows a CAPTCHA, sends a code to another email, or asks for an SMS.
- If Proton insists on SMS, close the tab and retry later from a normal home connection; flagged VPN ranges get the strictest check.
When a website insists on a phone
Plenty of services demand a number even when the email provider does not. The order that wastes least time:
- Look for an email-only path on the signup screen; several banks and stores hide it behind “Use email instead”.
- Check whether the number is for verification or recovery. Recovery numbers can often be added later or skipped.
- Use a number you control, not a public inbox: a code that anyone can read is not a verification. See protect your phone number privacy.
- Do not reuse one number across accounts if the provider links them; one number for multiple accounts explains where that breaks.
Recovery without a phone
A mailbox with no phone has exactly one weakness: account recovery. Cover it before you need it.
| Method | Where to set it | What happens if you lose it |
|---|---|---|
| Recovery email | Provider security settings | The second mailbox is the new single point of failure |
| Recovery code | Shown once at signup | Printed or stored in a password manager, it is the fastest reset |
| Authenticator app | Security settings | Works offline, but a new phone needs a migration plan |
| Printed backup | Paper in a drawer | Survives phone loss, malware and provider lockouts |
Two-factor with an authenticator app beats SMS anyway, and the email itself rarely needs a number once the account exists. If codes stop arriving at an existing mailbox, the fix is in email verification code not received.
Mistakes that cost accounts
- Using a throwaway inbox for anything you want to keep. Temp mail domains are deleted, blocklisted and public; temp mail has its own limits.
- Skipping the recovery code. Tuta and Proton both show it once.
- Adding no second contact. A provider that cannot verify you cannot restore you; the same rule applies to a lost phone number, as account recovery without a phone number sets out.
- Assuming Gmail will not ask. Google’s “optional” phone field can become mandatory on a flagged signup, a new device or a bulk IP range.
FAQ
Which email provider definitely does not require a phone?
Tuta and Mailfence document a phone-free signup; Proton Mail offers a route that can still fall back to SMS. Posteo and Mailbox.org, both paid, do not ask at all.
Can I use Gmail without a phone number?
Sometimes. Google lists the phone as optional, but demands it on many new accounts, especially from shared IPs or with a new device.
Is a temporary email the same as an email without a phone?
No. Temp mail needs no account at all and lasts minutes to days; a real provider gives you a mailbox you can recover. Use temp mail for a download link, not for a bank.
Will a phone-free email break two-factor authentication?
No. You can enable an authenticator app or a hardware key without ever adding a number, and that is stronger than SMS.
What if the provider asks for a phone halfway through signup?
Close the flow and retry later on a residential connection, or switch to Tuta or Mailfence. Entering a random number only locks the account behind a recovery you do not control.
What to do next
Start with Tuta if you want free and encrypted, Mailfence if you want an alternate-email check, and Proton if you already use its other tools. Save the recovery code the moment it appears, add an authenticator app, and only then start moving accounts onto the new address.